Author Comparison Project

Jimmy Ferguson, Robby Limon, April Stahl
Charles Dickens
A
Tale of Two Cities, David Copperfield
Biography:
Charles Dickens was born on February 7, 1812 at Landport (now
called
Some of the inheritance, left from a dead relative, was used to
pay for Dickens's education at a private school,
Dickens's first novel, The Pickwick Papers (1837), met with
huge popular success. Throughout the 1840s and 1850s, Dickens continued to work
tirelessly for social reform. In 1846 Dickens invested money in a new radical
newspaper, The Daily News, of
which he was editor. The paper was intended to provide a forum for Dickens's
ideas on social reform, but it failed. In 1850, Dickens became founding editor
of Household Words. He wrote
articles for this journal campaigning for parliamentary reform, public health,
better education for the poor, and reform of the workhouse system and legal
system. In 1836, Dickens married Catherine Hogarth, the daughter of the
newspaper editor George Hogarth. Some biographers believe that Dickens
preferred Catherine's sister, Mary, who moved into their house and died in 1837
at the age of 17 in Dickens's arms. From 1860, Dickens lived at
A
Tale of Two Cities – Plot Overview
Mr. Jarvis Lorry traveled to
A few years later, Darnay married Lucie Manette. He then reveled to her father his true
identity: Charles Evrémonde, nephew to the Marquis of
France. Shortly afterward the French
revolution started and Darnay’s former servant wrote a letter to Darnay asking
for his help. Darnay did not know of the
danger posed to him upon his return to
Darnay was condemned to death and in
order to save the husband of the one he loves, Sidney Carton disguises himself
as Darnay and Darnay as himself. This
allowed a switch to take place. Madame Defarge was killed by her own hand when
she fought Miss Pross and then her gun accidentally went off.
David Copperfield – Plot
Overview
The story
opens up with a fully grown David Copperfield narrating the story of his
upbringing and maturation. During his younger years, he lives contentedly with
his mother and their, Peggoty. While away on a vacation with Peggoty, his
mother marries Mr. Murdstone –while David and Peggoty
are away on a trip- who brings his sister, Miss Murdstone,
into the house. The Murdstones treat David cruelly, and David is sent away to a
boarding school for biting Mr. Murdstone.
While David and Peggoty are away, they visit
her family in
On his way to
Miss Betsey
visits
Dora and David
marry, and Dora turns out to be a terrible housewife, unable to complete her
daily chores. David loves her anyway and is generally happy. Miss Dartle, Mrs.
Steerforth’s ward, summons David and informs him that Steerforth has left
Little Em’ly. David and Mr. Peggoty enlist the help of Little Em’ly’s friend
Martha, who locates Little Em’ly leads Mr. Peggoty to her. During this time,
Dora falls ill and dies. David then leaves the country to travel abroad. David
continues to pursue his writing career with increasing commercial success.
Overview / Identification of Author
Style
1 Charles
Dickens frequently uses dwellings to symbolize the people that live within
them.
David Copperfield
“All
this I saw in the first glance after I crossed the threshold - child-like, according to my theory.” (38) – the house
represented the characteristics of the people living in it.
A Tale of two Cities
“It was a heavy mass of building, that
chateau of Monsieur the Marquis, with a large stone courtyard before it, and
two stone sweeps of staircase meeting in a stone terrace before the principal
door” (114) - the building of stone
symbolizes the stone heart of the marquis.
2 Simile
David Copperfield
“Two or,
three times in the course of the night, attired in a long flannel wrapper in
which she looked seven feet high, she appeared, like a disturbed ghost, in my
room…” (423)
A Tale of two Cities
Carton is described as a "rumored to be seen at broad day, going home stealthily and unsteadily
to his lodgings, like a dissipated cat" (90)
3 Metaphor
David Copperfield
“He soon
returned, greatly improved in appearance; but so rubicund, that I couldn't help
thinking his face had this in common with the lobsters, crabs, and crawfish…”
(39)
A Tale of two Cities
"It will seem nothing to you. Such whims
are only impressive as we originate them, I think; they are not to be
communicated. I have sometimes sat alone here of an evening, listening, until I
have made the echoes out to be the echoes of all the footsteps that are coming
by-and-bye into our lives."
4 Imagery
David Copperfield
The
idea of being again surrounded by those honest faces, shining welcome on me; of
renewing the peacefulness of the sweet Sunday morning, when the bells were
ringing, the stones dropping in the water, and the shadowy ships breaking
through the mist; of roaming up and down with little Em'ly, telling her my
troubles, and finding charms against them in the shells and pebbles on the
beach; made a calm in my heart” (123)
A Tale of two Cities
"As
a whirlpool of boiling water has a centre point, so, all this raging circled
around Defarge's wine-shop, and every human drop in the caldron had a tendency
to be sucked towards the vortex where Defarge himself, already begrimed with
gunpowder and sweat, issued orders, issued arms, thrust this man back, dragged
this man forward, disarmed one to arm another, labored and strove in the
thickest of the uproar." (211)
5 Personification
David Copperfield
“…and my
easy-chair imitating my aunt's much easier chair in its position at the open
window…” (430)
A Tale of two Cities
“These
fools [the aristocrats] know nothing. While they despise your breath, and would
stop it forever and ever, in you or in a hundred like you rather than in once
of their own horses or dogs, they only know what your breath tells them. Let it
deceive them, and then, a little longer; it cannot deceive them too much."
(171)
5 Critical Reads
“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times” for those unfortunate
many that happened to live in the time of A Tale of Two Cities (Dickens, A Tale
of Two Cities). Dickens conveys the truth that absolute power corrupts
absolutely in both the aforementioned novel and in his other novel David Copperfield
by the use of characterization, and symbolism (novelguide. com, David
Copperfield).
The characters within both of the previously referred to novels provide the
audience with a wealth of information as to Dickens’s main point. In the first
of the two novels, Dickens proves the aphorism that absolute power corrupts
absolutely. By the use of the character of Madam Defarge, a woman that
oppressed by the aristocratic society that made up pre-revolution
A second similarity within these two works exists in the use of commonplace
objects to represent something more. In David Copperfield, the sea represents
the harbinger of death, as it took the lives of Little Em’ly’s father, Ham and
Steerforth (Sparknotes. com, David Copperfield). However, the sea also assumes
the position of life-giver, as it allows men to make their livelihood solely
based on what the sea provides (novelguide. com, David Copperfield). It is no
mistake that Dora paints flowers. An author includes those small details for a
reason. Dickens’s reason is thus: flowers represent simplicity, innocence (Sparknotes.
com, David Copperfield). This simplicity makes itself evident in the
rearranging of the room: the old flowers symbolize this transformation of the
room back to its simple origin (Sparknotes. com, David Copperfield). Towards
the beginning of A Tale of Two Cities a wine cask breaks in front of Earnest
Defarge’s residence. The wine spattered upon the stone steps before the wine shop,
“all the people within reach had suspended their business, or their idleness,
to run to the spot and drink the wine” (Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities). The
people frenzied around the pooled red wine, foreshadowing the hysteria for
blood that consumes the people during the revolution (Sparknotes. com, A Tale
of Two Cities). This wine, symbolizing the blood yet to be spilt, “stained many
hands, and many faces, and many naked feet” just as the people become when they
lust for the life-giving fluid of the aristocrats. Dickens does not want the
reader to miss this symbol, so he even has one of his characters write the word
“BLOOD” upon a wall with the wine (Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities). In the
instance of the Marquis Evrémonde, both Dickens’s use of characterization and
symbolism shine brighter than a super-nova, revealing the symbol of the
aristocratic oppression of the meager. The Marquis runs down the child of
peasant and bats not an eyelash, sheds not a tear, feels not a care (Sparknotes.
com, A Tale of Two Cities). Like taking out the garbage. The Marquis knows no
remorse, just as the mob violence during the Reign of Terror knows no remorse.
Dickens uses footsteps to symbolize the many people that are to enter into the
life of Lucie and her family; Mr. Carton’s willingness to ‘take them into mine’
foreshadows his sacrifice for the sake of the family (novelguide. com, A Tale
of Two Cities: Metaphor Analysis), (Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities).
The two works of Dickens draw their effectiveness from multiple factors.
Symbols add a metaphysical aspect to the works and bring the reader into active
participation within the novel. Characters, in an almost allegorical manner,
add yet another level that allows the reader to immerse him or herself into the
novel.
Feminine
Archetypal Read
The power of women throughout life is ever present in life, and some authors
capture this message within their writing. However, few authors manifest it
with the same level of skill and fluidity that Charles Dickens possesses. Both
of his stories involve female characters who embody key figures in the
character’s lives and development. Within Dickens’ two works, A tale of two Cities, and David Copperfield, there are
numerous archetypes of various womanly figures throughout. Using these
characters and novels as his vehicle, he portrays the more major archetypal
roles of women in society and life as a whole.
The book, A Tale of Two Cities, takes place in
Dickens places a plethora of feminine archetypes within his other novel, and
they represent numerous different archetypes. The most prevalent of these
characters, David’s Mother, embodies the role of the loving mother. She
provides moral and emotional support for David as he endures hardship after
hardship. She is the one David always goes to when he needs someone to hold him
or otherwise act as a loving character. Similar to David’s Mother, Peggoty also
corresponds with a supporting figure. Her character embodies the working
servant, who supports the family as a whole. She is the warden of the family,
and takes care of David and his mother constantly, and as such is the archetype
for a helpful servant. Conversely, the character of Mr. Murdstone’s sister
characterizes the essence of a bad parenting figure. She routinely beats David,
and does not nurture him in any way. Dickens uses her as an example of bad
parenting, and a foil to Peggoty and David’s Mother. Lastly, the archetype of a
matriarch is made apparent through the character of Aunt Betsey. She leads
David’s life after his mother dies, and is the mentoring and governing body for
him as he matures and ages. She represents the stern feminine ruler in this
story, who governs David through life, yet still loves him at the same time.
Charles Dickens frequently displays feminine archetypes in his various novels,
and uses these characters as a literary representation of the roles women play
in society (in a non-sexist way). Each of his archetypal characters plays a key
role in the development of others, and is instrumental in the passage of the
plot. Further, his classic characters mirror the women of the age regardless of
what there role is, whether it is the matriarch or the mother or any other
conceivable occupation. Whether one reads A Tale of Two Cities, or David
Copperfield, or any other of Charles Dickens’ various novels, the supportive
role of feminine archetypes cannot be denied.
Political
Read
As a young man, Charles Dickens lived in prison with his convicted father, his mother, and his seven siblings. This was an experience that would scar him severely and turn him into one of the most accomplished writers of the 1800s. Not only did he found his own weekly periodical but he is also the author of a plethora of novels, including A Tale of Two Cities and his somewhat autobiographical work titled, David Copperfield. Dickens, like most other consummate novelists, used writing as a vessel to indirectly convey his morals and opinions. He commented on such issues as religion, human nature, and the government. Through character relationships, the presence of social ranks, and acknowledgement of significant historical events, Dickens makes his views on the political portion of society abundantly clear.
In his book, David Copperfield,
the main character David, idolizes his upper-class neighbor, Mr. Steerforth,
despite the cruel way he mocks people of a lower income. David look up to
Steerforth because he is wealthy, something David aspires to be. David does not
see that there are much more valuable possessions that one can obtain than
those of the material world. David does not seem to notice Steerforth’s
insensitive words about the Peggoty family, who are far less fortunate then he.
Through David’s eyes, the readers can see the division of social class between
Steerforth and The Peggoty family. David’s ignorance towards the fact that the
Peggotys are significantly kinder people that Steerforth , symbolizes society’s
blind quest to become wealthy and powerful and the ability of humans to
disregard the importance of kindness. Similar observations are to be made
about the book A Tale of Two Cities. In this novel, the aristocratic
class is notorious for treating the many poverty stricken citizens of
Within David Copperfield as well as A Tale of Two Cities, there is a great separation between upper and lower class. Steerforth represents the snobby upper division of society and the Peggotys family corresponds to the humble lower division. In this particular scenario, Dickens portrays the upper class as rude, uncaring, and arrogant and the lower class to be generous, accepting, and genuinely kind. David’s character is meant to signify the attitude and desire of most middle class members of society to be wealthy. Though he appreciates and recognizes the Peggoty’s compassion he sees Steerforth as the man that he wants to become. In A Tale of Two Cities, Dickens again places a hefty gap between the wealthy and the poor. The lower class barely has enough to sustain their lives while the rich and powerful enjoy a great amount of luxury. Again, Dickens illustrates his bitter emotions for those of a higher class and uses vast exaggeration to establish sympathy within readers for the poor and unfortunate working-class. He also utilizes significant historical events in his works of literature to better portray his beliefs.
David is a young man growing up in
Dickens has no problem with making his negative feelings clear about government and politics. He seems to often sympathize with the common man and make the wealthy man out to be the enemy. He also comments on the ignorance of society towards such matters as how they are being neglected by their leaders. Through A Tale of Two Cities and David Copperfield, Dickens uses character relationships, the presence of social ranks, and acknowledgement of significant historical events to portray his political beliefs and indirectly persuade his readers to believe the same.
David Copperfield
A Tale of Two Cities
David Copperfield
A Tale of Two Cities
David Copperfield
A Tale of Two Cities
QUIZ
1
What
childhood experience traumatized Dickens?
2
What was the
name of the paper the Dickens founded?
3
What was the
name of Dickens’s first novel?
4
Dickens’s final
novel was
a 1000 pages long
b about his childhood
c fiction
d unfinished
5
Darnay
eventually _________ Lucie.
a marries
b kills
c runs away
with
d runs away
from
6 How is David Copperfield (the child, not the book), treated during his early years by his stepfather?
a)-he treats him with a quiet disdain
b)-he treats him as the son he never had
c)-he is beaten regularly
d)-he caters to David’s every desire
7 The main difference between Peggoty and Steerforth, socially, is:
a)-Peggoty is rich, and Steerforth poor
b)-Steerforth is rich, and Peggoty is poor
c)-Peggoty is a noblewoman, and Steerforth a wealthy merchant
d)-Steerforth is a prince, and Peggoty is a pauper
8 Charles Dickens wrote Copperfield in part to show ____
a)-the weight that wealth had upon society
b)-the radical beliefs of a childhood friend
c)-to mock the royalty of the time
d)- to stand up for the writers of his time
9 The time period in which David Copperfield took place was ____
a)-early to mid 1600’s
b)-the beginning years of world war I
c)-mid 19th century Victorian England
d)-mid 18th century Victorian England
10 Mrs. Betsey embodies which archetype within the novel David Copperfield?
a)-the mother
b)-the care giver
c)-the matriarch
d)-the abusive, emotionally distant parent
11 Madame
Defarge represents which phrase within the novel, A Tale of Two Cities
a)-“Tis better to have loved and lost, then never to have loved at all”
b)-“Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned”
c)-“He(she) who fights and runs away, lives to fight another day”
d)-“Don’t put off to tomorrow, what can be done today”
12 What is NOT a role that the women play within these two works?
a)-The matriarch
b)-The high and mighty upper class
c)-The loving mother
d)-the scorned, vengeful woman
13 Who is the rich character in David Copperfield
14 What does David think about aristocrats?
15 During what revolution does A Tale of Two Cities Take Place?
16 What happens to David’s mother that makes it so that she cannot take care of him?
17 What does David represent?
18
Why did Lorry travel to
19 In A Tale of Two Cities it was the best of times for the _________ and the worst of times for the __________
20 What was Madam Defarge a symbol of?
21 This project is by _____________ ______________ ___________
22 Dickens died in _________
23 Dickens utilizes_____________ ______________ ___________ in his works of literature to better portray his beliefs.
24 5 literary devices Dickens uses.
25 How did Dickens pay for school?
Works
Cited
Dickens, Charles. A Tale of Two Cities.
—. David Copperfield. n.d.
novelguide. com. A Tale of Two Cities: Metaphor Analysis.02 34 2008 ...
—. David Copperfield.
31 03 2008 ...
Sparknotes. com. A Tale of Two Cities. 2006.31 march 2008 ...
—. David Copperfield. 2006.31 march 2008 ...