F. Scott Fitzgerald: Subjective Objectivity

Carolyn Bangasser

Saugus High School AP Literature Author Comparison Project

 

 

F. Scott Fitzgerald

 

 

The Great Gatsby and This Side of Paradise

 

 

Table of Contents

         I.      Fitzgerald Biography

       II.      Plot Overview: The Great Gatsby

    III.      Plot Overview: This Side of Paradise

   IV.      Style Elements

     V.      Critical Reads

Social Criticism

Historical

Biographical

Reader Response

   VI.      25 Question Quiz

  VII.      Works Cited

VIII.      Links

 

Author Biography

 

Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald was born on September 24, 1896, in St. Paul, Minnesota. He was born to a doting mother and a drinking yet socially graced father (Donaldson 1). Fitzgerald learned his father’s lovely manners and fit in with upper society. Fitzgerald’s passion for writing began very early in his life. During his years as a pupil, Fitzgerald wrote for “various school publications” leading up to his admission to Princeton University (Bruccoli 1). At Princeton, Fitzgerald played football and spent a great deal of his time writing “short stories, poems, plays, book reviews, and even jokes for the Nassau Literary Magazine” (Bruccoli 1). Due to low grades, he withdrew from the University and in the eve of World War I, enlisted in the U.S. Army. While away, Fitzgerald drafted his first novel, The Romantic Egoist, eventually re-titled This Side of Paradise (DIScovering 1). Also while in duty, he fell in love with Zelda Sayre, his own “golden girl.” Fitzgerald pursued Zelda ceaselessly until they were married the week after Paradise was published (Overview 1).

 

Fitzgerald led the extravagant lifestyle he wrote about. He was an alcoholic since his college years and it eventually took a toll on his health. Fitzgerald suffered two heart attacks before he died in 1940. At the time of his death, Fitzgerald was estranged from Zelda who suffered schizophrenia and was living with a mistress. He was also in debt due to his glamorous life (Encyclopedia).

 

Fitzgerald left behind a legacy in Modernist writing. He had the gift of observing and criticizing his own life from a different perspective. He left behind five major novels including This Side of Paradise and The Great Gatsby, the novel considered his masterpiece.

 

Gatsby Overview

            The Great Gatsby is written in the perspective of Nick Carraway, a young man looking back on the 1920s in utter lament. Nick recalls his time spent with a man who called himself Jay Gatsby. Gatsby was an enigma, a man of perceived wealth and status, yet viewed as unacceptable by the elite class. He had a past and an identity that he kept carefully concealed. The novel follows Gatsby’s plight to win the heart of Daisy Buchanan, his former sweetheart and current wife of Tom Buchanan. Gatsby attempts to reverse time and capture Daisy once more, to live with her as if they had never been separated. The novel is written in the era of Prohibition, a time Nick describes as lacking morals. Prohibition was simply a title with no weight. Alcohol and promiscuity reigned sovereign. Social mores were diminished. All agendas and goals collide leaving a wake of destruction, death and despair.

 

Paradise Overview

 

            This Side of Paradise follows the observational Amory Blaine, a mirror image of a young Fitzgerald. Amory is a precocious youth, raised by his mother, Beatrice, whom Amory addresses by her first name. Amory is a keen observer of social hierarchy and is determined to find himself among the elite. He attends many prestigious schools including St. Regis Preparatory and Princeton University. While attending school, Amory is obsessed with his own social advancement and participates in activities that he believes will aid him in his crusade. Following college, Amory goes off to fight in World War I and while he is away, Beatrice dies. Amory’s close relationship with his mother is the first episode in his issues with women. Amory endures several heartbreaks that leave him disillusioned and hurt. Amory also loses his father figure, Monsignor Darcy, his mother’s early lover. Amory returns to Princeton in newfound poverty, condemning capitalism and spewing socialist sentiments. Penniless and unglued, Amory marches on in his egotistic existence.

 

 

 

F. Scott Fitzgerald Style Elements:

 

  • Hyperbole

--“he seemed still to hear the wind sobbing around him” (Paradise, Book 2, ch.3, para. 1).

 

--“the world and its mistress returned to Gatsby’s house” (Fitzgerald, 61).

 

  • Character Development through Inner thought

--“Amory wondered how people could fail to notice that he was a boy marked for glory” (Paradise, Ch.1 para. 133).

 

--“ When I came back from the East last autumn  felt that I wanted the world to be in uniform and at a sort of moral attention forever” (Fitzgerald, 2).

 

  • Characterization through Objective Observation

--“School ruined his French and gave him a distaste for standard authors. His masters considered him idle, unreliable and superficially clever” (Paradise, Ch.1, para. 131).

 

--“I’d got a strong impression that he was picking his words with care” (Fitzgerald, 48)

 

  • Cultural Allusions to Feminism and Sexual Liberation:

 

--“I don't want to think about pots and kitchens and brooms. I want to worry whether my legs will get slick and brown when I swim in the summer” (Paradise, Book 2, Ch.1, para. 416).

 

--“And Daisy ought to have something in her life,’ murmured Jordan” (Fitzgerald, 79).

 

  • Political Allusions to Prohibition:

 

--“Tom came out of the house wrapping a quart bottle in a towel” (Fitzgerald, 120).

 

--“The advent of prohibition with the ‘thirsty-first’ put a sudden stop to the submerging of Amory's sorrows” (Paradise, Book 2, Ch.2, para. 164).

 

 

King of the Mountain: Social Criticism Read

 

            Social ladders are forever crowded with people relentlessly striving to reach the top and ultimate glory: status. The apex of society’s hierarchal pyramid holds the key to man’s desires of wealth, fortune, and fame. F. Scott Fitzgerald, in his novels The Great Gatsby and This Side of Paradise, examines the art of social advancement. Fitzgerald’s novels highlight the snobbery that characterizes a generation of bored men and women of the upper class

 

             The Great Gatsby shows the title character’s desperate pursuit of wealth and status—a prize he cannot win. Jay Gatsby seeks to establish himself through accumulating material treasure. He builds himself a modest palace, spends lavishly, behaves pretentiously, and lives extravagantly. He claims love for Miss Daisy Buchanan, his former sweetheart, a currently married woman. However, Gatsby’s pursuit of Daisy does not involve her at all, rather, what she can get him. Daisy is “the golden girl.” Through Daisy, Gatsby can pull himself above the striving man on the social ladder and become the accomplished man. Sadly according to society’s standards, Gatsby is still not good enough. For his mansion is in the less fashionable part of the island, he is obviously new money, and his lustful affair is his downfall. Gatsby is exposed as a common man who simply could not survive the climb, a fraud.

 

            This Side of Paradise follows the growth of Amory Blaine, a young man with a keen eye for social patterns. Amory is a cultured and sophisticated young man and as such he struggles socially at his boarding school. While Amory attends the school, he takes care to notice ways to establish himself. Amory notes two types of men at his new school: the “Big Man” and “The Slicker.” Big men have a lackadaisical approach to education, appearance and school activities yet still attain success, while the slicker is characterized by his slicked hair and social and academic success. Amory decides his aspirations lie in the “Big Man.” He joins the football team as a means to gain popularity at his prep school. Once he advances to Princeton, Amory continues football, only to be sidelined due to an injury. Upon this event, Amory searches for a new way to gain social status and joins the Princeton newspaper. Amory is determined to be among the respected class. Once he realizes that his work on the paper is not helping him attain his goal, he abandons the effort. Amory carefully analyzes society, trying to find the place where he fits. His obsession with social hierarchy is revealed in his thoughts and through his actions. Amory is determined to be among the unconventional and the revered. Towards the end of the novel, Amory finds himself poor and disillusioned. He expresses socialist sentiments.

 

Fitzgerald’s writing provides insight into the social hierarchy of the time period. The elevated few cast condescending stares upon the lesser men struggling to reach the top level of esteem. As seen in Amory and Gatsby, a man may do his best to improve himself and his conditions; he may work ceaselessly to achieve a sense of aggrandizement—only to be crushed by the harsh reality of social restrictions. Nouveau riche is simply unfashionable and unacceptable

 

F. Scott Fitzgerald: Historical

  • Fitzgerald writes in the era following World War I in the style called Modernism. Modernism is characterized by post war disillusionment and a sense of existentialism.
  • Both novels take place in the time preceding the Great Depression commonly dubbed the Roaring Twenties
  • Prohibition is an underlying theme in both novels
  • Promiscuity is a theme in both novels as the fruit of sexual liberation
  • Gatsby features ties to the Mafia
  • Amory fights in World War I and returns with socialist sentiments

 

 

F. Scott Fitzgerald: Biographical

  • Fitzgerald’s Gatsby follows the title character’s quest for Daisy Buchanan. In his own life, Fitzgerald pursued his own “golden girl,” Zelda Sayre.
  • Fitzgerald’s personal alcohol problem is reflected in his characters
  • Fitzgerald himself led the glamorous celebrity lifestyle. Like his characters in Gatsby, the life led to his downfall due to alcoholism, debt, and detached relationships.
  • Much like the Buchanans, the Fitzgeralds lived in the Prohibition era—but that meant nothing but rebellion. They embraced the life of the Roaring Twenties.
  • In Paradise, Rosalind breaks her engagement with Amory due to his failure to convince her that he could afford her. Zelda Sayre did the same to Fitzgerald.
  • Fitzgerald attended Princeton University as does his character Amory Blaine.

 

 

F. Scott Fitzgerald: Reader Response

  • Paradise is an examination of the struggles of the youth of the Lost Generation.
  • Gatsby is a testimony against the flamboyant lifestyle common in the 1920s.
  • Both novels examine social hierarchy and social mores of the time period.
  • Feminism coupled with lingering restriction is present in both novels
  • Reader relates to struggles of the characters: morality, independence, desire vs. duty

 

 

Quiz

1. F. Scott Fitzgerald was a member of

a)     Veteran’s Society

b)     The Lost Generation

c)      The British Navy

d)     The Dead Poet’s Society

 

2. Evidence supports the hypothesis that Fitzgerald’s This Side of Paradise is clearly

a)     A political criticism

b)     A feminist criticism

c)      A work of autobiographical fiction

d)     An attack on capitalism

 

3. Amory Blaine’s relationship with Rosalind parallels the relationship of

a)     Gatsby and Daisy

b)     Monsignor Darcy and Beatrice

c)      Fitzgerald and Zelda Sayre

d)     Tom and Daisy

 

4. Which of the following are prominent themes in The Great Gatsby

                                 I.      Time

                               II.      Lust

                              III.      Economic distress

                           IV.      Moral decay

a) I and IV only

b) I and II only

c) III and I only

d) I, II and IV only

 

5. ______and______are alluded to in both novels.

a)     Propaganda and materialism

b)     Socialism and Economic Depression

c)      Feminism and Prohibition

d)     Prohibition and Judeo Christianity

 

6. As a student, Amory Blaine is extremely interested in

a)     Football

b)     Fraternities

c)      Writing

d)     Social hierarchy

 

7. Fitzgerald dubbed the 1920s

a)     The Jazz Age

b)     The Roaring Twenties

c)      The Flapper Era

d)     The Gilded Era

 

8. Fitzgerald wrote in the______ style.

a)     Post Modernist

b)     Romantic

c)      Modernist

d)     Realist

 

9. Nick Carraway is

a)     Gatsby’s chauffeur

b)     The apprentice of T.J. Eckleburg

c)      Tom’s second cousin

d)     Narrator and Daisy’s cousin

 

10. Amory’s elevation of socialism stems from

a)     His new found poverty

b)     His disillusionment with war

c)      His loss of family, especially his mother

d)     His exhaustion with social advancement

 

11. Fitzgerald attended which college?

a)     Cambridge

b)     Princeton

c)      Yale

d)     Brown

 

12. What does Daisy represent to Gatsby?

a)     Wealth and status

b)     Rebellion and independence

c)      Love and romance

d)     Youth and time

 

13. “He seemed still to hear the wind sobbing around him” is an example of

a)     Metaphor

b)     Hyperbole

c)      Apostrophe

d)     Litotes

 

14. Amory Blaine attends

a)     Windermere Preparatory

b)     Horace Green Preparatory

c)      Charm School

d)     St. Regis Preparatory

 

15. What does Amory call his mother?

a)     Beatrice

b)     Mum

c)      Bertha

d)     Mother

 

16. Fitzgerald’s colleagues include all BUT:

a)     Ernest Hemingway

b)     Gertrude Stein

c)      James Joyce

d)     John Steinbeck

 

17. Daisy and Rosalind represent

a)     Fully liberated women

b)     The suffrage movement and sexual liberation of women

c)  Women struggling between personal desires and outer expectations

d) Flappers

 

18. Disillusionment, social examination, and unsure future characterize

a)     Modernism

b)     Post War sentiments

c)      Fitzgerald’s personal struggles

d)     Socialist longings

 

19. Fitzgerald suffered from

a)     Schizophrenia

b)     Multiple Personality Disorder

c)      Alcoholism

d)     Manic Depression

 

20. Amory is sexually attracted to his mother and therefore is incapable of loving any other woman

—this is an example of

a)     A perverted read

b)     A Freudian read

c)      An Oedipal read

d)     A Disturbing read

 

21. Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald was named after his famous relative who

a)     Signed the Declaration of Independence

b)     Was a World War I hero

c)      Wrote the Star Spangled Banner

d)     Was known as Frankie by his friends

 

22. Fitzgerald condemned the extravagant lifestyle his characters lived and

a)     Ironically lived it himself, providing insight

b)     Renounced alcohol and promiscuity

c)      Lived as a hermit

d)     Drank moderately

 

23. Amory, like Fitzgerald, did all of the following EXCEPT:

a)     Attended Princeton University

b)     Played football

c)      Fought in World War I

d)     Married his ideal

 

24. Zelda Fitzgerald suffered from

a)     Schizophrenia

b)     Multiple Personality Disorder

c)      Alcoholism

d)     Manic Depression

 

25. Me llamo

a)     Barack

b)     Hillary

c)      Carolyn

d)     John

 

 

 

Works Cited

 

Bruccoli, Matthew J., and Arlyn Bruccoli. "Fitzgerald, F. Scott (1896-1940)." American Decades.  McConnell, Tandy. Online ed.  Detroit: Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center - Gold. Gale. Saugus High School15 Apr. 2008 
<http://find.galegroup.com/ips/start.do?prodId=IPS>.

 

Donaldson, Scott. "F. Scott Fitzgerald." DISCovering Authors. Online ed. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center - Gold. Gale. Saugus High School. 15 Apr. 2008 <http://find.galegroup.com/srcx/infomark.do?&contentSet=GSRC&type=retrieve&tabID=T001&prodId=SRC1&docId=EJ2101203607&source=gale&srcprod=SRCG&userGroupName=saug30122&version=1.0>.

 

Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. New York: Scribner, 1925.

 

Fitzgerald, F. Scott. This Side of Paradise. New York: Scribner, 1920; Bartleby.com, 1999. www.bartleby.com/115/.

 

"Fitzgerald, F(rancis) Scott (Key) (1896-1940)." DISCovering Authors. Online ed.  Detroit: Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center - Gold. Gale. Saugus High School15 Apr. 2008 
<http://find.galegroup.com/ips/start.do?prodId=IPS>.

 

"Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald." Encyclopedia of World BiographyVol. 5. 2nd ed. Detroit: Gale, 2004. 3 pp. 23 vols. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Gale. Saugus High School15 Apr. 2008 
<http://find.galegroup.com/ips/start.do?prodId=IPS>.

 

"F. Scott Fitzgerald." DISCovering Authors. Online ed.  Detroit: Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center - Gold. Gale. Saugus High School15 Apr. 2008 
<http://find.galegroup.com/ips/start.do?prodId=IPS

 

"On F. Scott Fitzgerald." DISCovering Authors. Online ed.  Detroit: Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center - Gold. Gale. Saugus High School15 Apr. 2008 
<http://find.galegroup.com/ips/start.do?prodId=IPS>.

 

 

Links

 

http://www.sauguscenturions.com/maghakian/authorprojects.html

 

http://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/database/fitzgerald_f_homepage.html

 

http://www.online-literature.com/fitzgerald/

 

http://www.fitzgeraldsociety.org/life/index.html

 

http://www.bartleby.com/115/

 

http://www.kirjasto.sci.fi/fsfitzg.htm